The service was great, food was delicious the chicken souvlaki was prepared to perfection, moist, tender and melted in your mouth. Even the pita was grilled to perfection. Check out the grill marks below. The Gyros looked awesome from across the table. Price was affordable certainly for the quality of the food. Had two soups and split a platter which came with a salad and rice with my wife. It was a good healthy meal without overeating. The owner/server was attentive and you could tell took pride in his food and establishment. The empty plate once did hold for about 30 seconds Mom's disappearing and amazing baklava! ...treat yourself and enjoy.

First off, this restaurant is a true gem. Tucked away middle of the block off hempstead turnpike. I have tried every single greek restaurant on the island. The best greek salad with grilled chicken ever, served with moist warm soft pita bread. It's a very small restaurant. However, I had to ask the owner how is the chicken is so moist it melts in your mouth. He mentioned it's pure organic. Don't hesitate or think twice. Give them a try. You will be a customer for a very long time. The brothers are super friendly and the restaurant and its kitchen are meticulously cleaned. Parking is kind of hard . But by far the best greek food out on the island . Clean flavors and generous with the feta and service beyond excellent

Had an awesome meal at Greek Brothers Restaurant! We started with the avgolemono soup, and it was spot on—rich, creamy, and full of flavor. I got the beef and lamb gyro pita sandwich, which was super tasty and perfectly seasoned, and my wife had the Greek salad with shrimp—fresh, light, and delicious. The shrimp were cooked just right! Great service and a nice, relaxed vibe. We’ll definitely be back!

Friendly staff. The first time here, I had the Keftedakia. It took only about 5 minutes to prepare. When I opened it and caught a whiff, I knew they were going to be awesome. They were crusty on the outside while tender on the inside. The herbs and spices gave them a great flavor and aroma. The tzatziki sauce was spot on and elevated the meatballs even further. The 5 meatballs were a perfect portion for my drive back to New Jersey.

I have enjoyed eating here many times since they opened and just did a large catering order with them for a party and they did not disappoint! Ordering was a breeze with chef Stavros talking me through the whole menu and guiding me in flavors and amounts for a group of 12. The hospitality of the owners is incredible. We always feel so welcome whenever we're there and it was so great to see that same level of care in the catering. We picked the food up and everything was freshly made with such love and care, and was hot and ready to serve right away. My guests were blown away by the quality and flavors of the food, all asking for menus on their way out. The portions were extremely generous, the food was so delicious, and we can't wait to order again for our next party!

THIS PLACE IS AMAZING TAKES YOU BACK TO GREECE! From the beers to the food to the desserts I always look forward to coming to Greek brothers and having a nice cold beer and an amazing chicken gyro platter that takes me back to Greece !!

Hands down the best authentic greek spot long island has to offer and I’ve tried them all. The issue on long island is that all greek spots claim to be authentic and traditional but they don’t compare to this place. Long island complains about prices and portion sizes all the time. I wish long island would understand good quality when they have it. Instead we are concerned with over sized portions for a slightly better price but the quality is terrible. The pita’s at Greek Brothers are mouth watering and delicious. All the ingredients are fresh. All dishes are made in house. The owner served us and was incredibly kind and attentive. If you taste a pita from this place and any place on long island blindfolded hands down this wins every time. Do yourself a favor and give it a try and you will be happy you did.

Greek Brothers offers an exceptional dining experience that seamlessly blends authentic Greek flavors with outstanding service. From the moment you step in, the warm and inviting atmosphere sets the tone for a memorable meal. The menu is a treasure trove of Greek delights, with standout dishes like the pork gyro, praised for its flavorful meat and delectable tzatziki sauce. Desserts such as the baklava and Greek cheese cake come highly recommended, offering a sweet conclusion to your meal. What truly elevates the dining experience is the attentive and accommodating staff. Their commitment to customer satisfaction is evident, making each guest feel valued and welcomed. The owners’ dedication to quality and hospitality shines through, contributing to the restaurant’s stellar reputation. With its combination of authentic cuisine, impeccable service, and excellent management, Greek Brothers has rightfully earned its place as a local favorite. A visit promises not just a meal, but a delightful journey into Greek culinary tradition.